For several years, there has been some concern about lead in lipstick. To date, there is no evidence of high levels of lead in lipstick, though some brands do contain very small amounts of lead.
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulates cosmetics sold in the United States under the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act. Under the act, the FDA doesn't subject cosmetics, including lipstick, to scrutiny and approval before these products are marketed. The exception is most lipstick color additives, which are screened before being marketed. FDA regulations for approved color additives allow trace levels of heavy metals, including lead. To date, the FDA has not determined these levels to be a health threat. Other ingredients in lipsticks, such as waxes and oils, are not subject to FDA testing.
The FDA is developing a lead test for lipsticks and says that it intends to publish results in a peer-reviewed scientific journal. Meantime, there is no recommendation from the FDA that restricts the use of lipsticks because of lead.
| Lipsticks with less than 0.02 parts per million (ppm) lead | |||||
| Brand | Product
Name/Shade | Lead | Parent
Company | State | Purchase
Date |
| Avon | Ultra Color Rich
Cherry Jubilee | <0.02 | Avon | MA* | 08/27/07 |
| Body Shop | Lip Colour Garnet | <0.02 | L'Oreal | MA | 08/27/07 |
| Body Shop | Lip Colour Garnet | <0.02 | L'Oreal | CA | 08/27/07 |
| Clinique | Long Last
Lipstick Merlot | <0.02 | Estee Lauder | MA | 08/27/07 |
| Dior | Replenishing Lipcolor
Red Premiere | <0.02 | LVMH | MA | 08/27/07 |
| Estee Lauder | Maraschino | <0.02 | Estee Lauder | MN | 08/26/07 |
| MAC | Matte Lipstick
Viva Glam 1 | <0.02 | Estee Lauder | MA | 08/27/07 |
| Revlon | Superlustrous Love
That Red | <0.02 | Revlon | CT | 08/27/07 |
| Revlon | Superlustrous
Bed of Roses | <0.02 | Revlon | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Revlon | Colorstay Lipcolor
Red Velvet | <0.02 | Revlon | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Tarte | Inside Out
Vitamin Lipstick | <0.02 | Tarte | MA | 08/27/07 |
| Wet N Wild | Wild Mega Colors
Cherry Blossom | <0.02 | Markwins | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Wet N Wild | Wild Mega Colors
Cherry Blossom | <0.02 | Markwins | CT | 08/27/07 |
| Lipsticks with detectable levels of lead but less than 0.1 ppm lead (the FDA-recommended limit for candy) | |||||
| MAC | Matte Lipstick
Viva Glam | 0.03 | Estee Lauder | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Revlon | Love That Red | 0.03 | Revlon | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Cover Girl | Queen Collection
Ruby Remix | 0.03 | P & G | CT | 08/27/07 |
| Clinique | Long Last Paprika | 0.03 | Estee Lauder | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Dior | Replenishing Lipcolor
Red Premiere | 0.04 | LVMH | CA | 08/26/07 |
| Body Shop | Garnet | 0.06 | L'Oreal | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Wet N Wild | Cherry Frost | 0.06 | Markwins | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Clinique | Red | 0.09 | Estee Lauder | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Burt's Bees | Lip Shimmer Merlot | 0.09 | Burt's Bees | MA | 08/29/07 |
| Lipsticks with lead levels higher than 0.1 ppm | |||||
| Maybelline | NY Moisture Extreme
Scarlet Simmer | 0.11 | L'Oreal | CT | 08/27/07 |
| Cover Girl | Incredifull Lipcolor
Maximum Red | 0.12 | P & G | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Peacekeeper | Paint Me
Compassionate | 0.12 | Peacekeeper | MA | 08/27/07 |
| Maybelline | NY Moisture Extreme
Midnight Red | 0.18 | L'Oreal | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Maybelline | NY Moisture Extreme
Cocoa Plum | 0.19 | L'Oreal | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Dior | Addict Positive Red | 0.21 | LVMH | CA | 08/23/07 |
| Cover Girl | Continuous Color
Cherry Brandy | 0.28 | P & G | CA | 08/23/07 |
| L'Oreal | Colour Riche
True Red | 0.50 | L'Oreal | MN | 08/26/07 |
| Cover Girl | Incredifull Lipcolor
Maximum Red | 0.56 | P & G | MN | 08/26/07 |
| L'Oreal | Colour Riche
Classic Wine | 0.58 | L'Oreal | CT | 08/27/07 |
| L'Oreal | Colour Riche
True Red | 0.65 | L'Oreal | CA | 08/23/07 |
Sources:
Lawrence E. Gibson, M.D.
http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/lead-in-lipstick/AN01618
http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20071012/lipstick_chart_071012/20071012/
Important Notice: Information provided is for general background purposes and is not intended as a substitute for medical diagnosis or treatment by a trained professional. You should always consult your community pharmacist or physician about any health care questions you may have, especially before trying a new medication, diet, fitness program, or approach to health care issues.
No comments:
Post a Comment